Our Menu
Daily Specials and Desserts...Just Ask!
Tavern Starters
Turtle Wings
$10.18
8 chicken wings smoked, tossed in served with ranch or blue cheese dressing with carrots and celery. Also available in boneless. Choices include House, Hot, Medium, Mild, Hot Garlic, Garlic Parmesan, Sweet chili, BBQ, Extreme Heat, Sweet Heat, Blackened or Cajun Rub. Have them grilled for $1
Chislic
$9.18
Tender, marinated steak grilled to perfection with toast points.
Monument Circle Rings
$8.18
Basket of onion rings to share.
Dillinger Fries
$6.18
Basket of Hand-cut fries to share. Try them with Cajun Seasoning or Hot seasoning. Order Loaded w/ spicy Blanco cheese, bacon, and siracha Ranch Add $4 Add Chili $1, Cheese $1, Sour Cream and/or Jalapeno $.50.
TeePee Cheese and Sausage
$7.79
Smoked Cajun sausage with cheese cubes and a balsamic drizzle.
Garfield Park-chos
$8.79
Crispy tortilla chips topped with cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, onions and jalapenos. Add Pulled Pork $3, Chicken $3 or Chili $1.
Manual Sticks
$5.79
Housemade sticks served with garlic butter or nacho cheese.
Indy 500 Fingers
$8.79
3 Hand-Breaded chicken fingers served with a sauce of your choice.
Pepper Jack Balls
$8.79
House made pepper Jack fried cheese balls served with ranch dressing.
Tavern Sandwiches
Chip substitutions: Coleslaw, Cottage Cheese or Hand-cut fries $1.50. Side Caesar or House salad $2.50. Cheese Selection: American, Pepper-Jack or Swiss.
*Hattie Melt
$8.18
Patty melt on rye bread with Swiss cheese, grilled onions and Thousand Island dressing. Served with chips.
*Double Barringer's Bar Burger
$10.79
Two hand-pressed patties crisped to perfection with mayo, shredded lettuce, pickle, tomato, and red onion. Served with chips. Add cheese, bacon, chili, or pulled pork $1 Jalapenos or grilled onions $.50.
*The Meridian
$8.79
(Hamburger or Veggie Burger). Served with chips. Dressed as you like . Add cheese, bacon, chili, or pulled pork $1.00.
Hoosier Sandwich
$10.18
Hand-Cut Pork Tenderloin (Breaded or Grilled) Served with chips. Dressed as you like. Cheese or bacon $1.00.
Parkway Dog
$7.18
1/4 pound all-beef hot dog. Make it a chili cheese dog!! Served with chips. Add Chili or Cheese $1.
Last Chance Dog
$7.18
1/4 pound all-beef hot dog wrapped in bacon and deep-fried. Side of sweet relish and sriracha sour cream. Served with chips. Add chili or cheese $1.
Georgetown Sandwich
$8.79
BLT Sandwich served with mayo on the side. Served with chips
Key West Fish & Chips
$10.79
Hand-battered cod and Hand-cut fries with our house-made tartar sauce.
Prohibition Pork
$9.18
Smoked and served on a bun with BBQ sauce on the side. Served with chips. Dressed as you like. Cheese or bacon $1.
Smith Valley Grilled Ham & Cheese
$9.18
Served with chips. Add bacon $1.
Southie Cheese
$9.79
Grilled cheese with our house BBQ pulled pork on the inside. Served with chips. Add Bacon $1.
Chicken Sandwhich
$9.18
Breaded or Grilled and dressed how you like and served w/ chips!
Salads
Dressings: House-made Ranch, Honey Mustard, Creamy Italian, Blue Cheese, French and Thousand Island.
Unser Caesar Salad
$6.79
Romaine lettuce with croutons and parmesan cheese. Add grilled chicken for $3.00.
AJ Salad
$9.79
Chef Salad—iceberg lettuce with tomato, red onion, ham, o cheese, and croutons.
1879 Salad
$9.79
Grilled or fried chicken iceberg lettuce salad with tomato, red onion, ham, cheese and croutons.
Al Capone Salad
$9.79
Taco seasoned chicken—lettuce, tomato, onion, cheese, and tortilla strips with salsa ranch dressing.
Sides
Coleslaw
$2.00
Cottage Cheese
$2.00
House Fries
$2.00
Wing Sauce Side
$0.75
Side House/Side Caesar Salad
$3.00
Bowl of Chili
$5.00
Basket of Chips or Chex Mix
$1.00
pizza
Pizza
Sizes available 6", 10", 12" and 16".
Toppings:
Pork Topping, Italian Sausage, Peperoni, Ham, Bacon, Hamburger, Black Olives, Green Olives, Onion, Mushrooms, Fresh and Pickled Jalapeno, Tomatoes, Green Pepper, Zucchini.
The 1879
$16.00/10"
$20.00/12"
$24.00/16"
Pork Sausage, Pepperoni, Black Olives, Onion, and Zucchini.
Death by Scorpion Sauce Pie
$16.00/10"
$20.00/12"
$24.00/16"
Italian Sausage, Peperoni, Black Olives, Fresh Jalapeno, Onion, and Drizzled with Scorpion Sauce.
Last Chance Pie
$16.00/10"
$20.00/12"
$24.00/16"
Peperoni, Pork Sausage, Onion, Mushroom, and Green Pepper.
Katie Bug Pie
$16.00/10"
$20.00/12"
$24.00/16"
Mushroom, Tomatoes, Onion, Zucchini, Crumbled Veggie Patty.
Cutie Pie
$16.00/10"
$20.00/12"
$24.00/16"
Ham, Bacon, Mushroom, Onion and Tomatoes.
The Duke
$16.00/10"
$20.00/12"
$24.00/16"
Pork Sausage, Italian Sausage, Pepperoni, Bacon, Ham
Pizza Sides
Cheese Bread
With Smoked Provolone
Pizza Desserts
Cannoli
Dessert Pizza
Toppings Vary